Beggar's Pizza Information

Walking into Beggar's Pizza on Sheffield Avenue, you immediately notice the warm, inviting vibe that makes it feel more like a local hangout than just another pizza spot. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere is complemented by cheerful staff who are quick to greet you and make recommendations, setting the stage for a relaxed dining experience. The menu is refreshingly diverse, offering everything from classic hand-tossed pizzas to hearty sandwiches and inventive pasta dishes, each prepared with a focus on fresh ingredients and generous portions. The signature pizzas stand out not just for their perfectly crisp crusts and melty cheese, but for the creative topping combinations that keep regulars coming back. Patrons rave about the wings and garlic bread, both of which strike a satisfying balance between flavor and texture, while the daily specials often introduce playful twists on traditional favorites, reflecting the kitchen’s flair for variety. Dining at Beggar's Pizza is enhanced by its convenient location in Dyer, making it an easy stop for both a casual weeknight dinner or a lively weekend gathering. The reviews consistently highlight not only the quality of the food but also the attentive, friendly service, which turns a simple meal into a memorable experience. Whether you're ordering takeout or settling in for a meal on-site, the pace is comfortable and the staff ensures that every order is handled with care, keeping the experience smooth from start to finish. The atmosphere, combined with the menu variety and local charm, makes it clear why this spot has earned a loyal following among Dyer residents and visitors alike, offering a reliably satisfying and approachable dining option for anyone craving pizza, pasta, or classic comfort fare.

Most Popular Dishes

  • Turkey Burger $12.95

8oz Turkey patty, lettuce, tomato, onion, hamburger bun.

  • Hamburger $18.15

8 oz ground beef patty, lettuce, tomato, onion on Hamburger Bun.

  • Regular Wings $11.80

6 or 12 pieces boned in wings (wingettes and drumettes) fried and served with your choice of sauce.

  • Boneless Wings $12.95

8oz of boneless chicken breaded, fried and served with your choice of dipping sauce. 7-9 pieces

  • Freddy Bowl $10.30

Italian Sausage Patty chopped and topped with Marinara, sweet peppers, and choice of cheese. No Bread

  • Big Cheese Bowl $16.05

6 oz of Italian Beef topped with Mozzarella and Provolone cheese and your choice of sauce served in a bowl. No Bread

  • Hamburger Bowl $14.90
  • Italian Beef Bowl $12.60

Italian Beef, choice of Sauce. No Bread

Open Times

Monday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Tuesday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Wednesday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Thursday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Friday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Saturday 12:00 PM - 09:00 PM

Sunday 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM

Icon

Location & Contact

Contact Details

  • 3344 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 46311, United States
  • Right Now :
  • +1 219-322-4448

What People's Say About Place

We ordered two family size pizzas from Beggars Pizza and they were fantastic. One was sausage, pepperoni, and jalapeño (crispy), and the other was sausage (crispy). Both pizzas were cooked perfectly; crispy crust, well-balanced toppings, and great flavor in every bite. Everything tasted fresh and was done just right. We were very happy with our order and will definitely be ordering again!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 – Great Spot Under New Management! Beggars Pizza in Dyer is truly stepping up under new management. The place feels cozy and welcoming, and the food is delicious — perfect for a casual lunch or a relaxed dinner. What really makes this location special is the new management. The owners are active on the floor, checking on customers, running the bar, and making sure everyone is taken care of. Their kindness and involvement create a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that’s hard to find. Little by little, this spot is becoming one of a kind. Whether you’re coming with family or just stopping in to eat, I highly recommend it.

First time eating here. Our waitress accidentally gave us a Italian beef, pepperoni and cheese pizza, instead of Italian Sausage and pepperoni. Best mix up! It was a great pizza! They were so apologetic, they gave us our Italian sausage and pepperoni pizza to go, but we told them we truly enjoyed the Italian beef and pepperoni pizza. Super friendly, caring staff. It did not disappoint.

Our family absolutely loves Beggars Pizza Dyer! The food is always amazing and the workers are so friendly! The new owners have definitely helped out. They are always active and attentive. Would definitely recommend for carry out, delivery, or dining in!! 10/10!

Food was great....both the pizza and Italian beef. Beer was ice cold. Service was phenomenal from Kris and Anabel. Will be back soon!

We have been eating here for many years and have always enjoyed the experience and the food. The pizza is one of our favorites and the beef sandwich is our other favorite to order. Cold beer and good food is a great combination!

Beggar's has always been one of my favorite pizzas. Made perfect every single time until tonight. I should have given a 5 review in the past. I've even been to several different locations. My pizza from the dyer location wasn't terrible but it was the first time it wasn't perfect. About 20% of my pizza didn't have cheese. Shocking! Just wanted to let you know. I really hope someone from Beggar's reads this review. It was something I would expect from a $20 pizza not a $34 pizza.

Hey guys needed a quick lunch the other day or some workers at the job site pulled in Dyer BEGGARS PIZZA they had a whole variety of different slices. Got six slices and was out the door in less than three minutes. Very nice people to deal with.

Places Nearby